1885  Thetford               (NSC)     H   1-0          Sadler
1891  Swaffham                         A   0-3                   
1896  Norwich CEYMS           (NCC)    -   3-0          Sneath, Medlock, Orviss
1903  Ipswich Town                     A   4-4        Stevens 2, Ransome, ?
1908  Yarmouth                         A   4-4          Hitchcock. Davison, Bannister, ?
1925  Kirkley                          A   0-0
 1931  Newark Town             (FAC)    H   1-1    3500  Walker (pen)
1936  Thetford                         A   3-1          John, Henry, Mitchley
1959  Aldershot               (FAC)    H   3-1     6533 Dixon 2, Luke 1
1964  Shrewsbury Town         (FAC)    H   0-1    4183
1967  Cambridge City          (EPFL)   A   1-3      -   Clarke
1970  Wimbledon                        H   0-2    1134 
1973  Boston United           (EPFL)   H   1-1     418      Elliot
1981  Netherfield                      H   0-1     603
1984  Bedworth United                  H   1-1     510      Foster
1987  Trowbridge Town                  A   2-0          Money, Howard
1992  Dudley Town                      A   0-2     112  
1995  Hinckley Town                    A   3-4     114  Bloodworth, McNamara (pen), Matthews
1998  Weymouth                         A   0-1     885
2006  Banbury United                   A   3-3     420  Frew, Smith, Melton
2009  Ossett Town                      H   7-2     812  Appiah 2, Aisien 2, Spencer 2, Story              
2015  Nantwich Town      (FAT)         A   1-5    329  Gaughran                                                      9
2017  Royston Town                     H   4-0    514  Clunan (pen), Hawkins 2, Gash                                 1