1898  Old Malverians          (AC)     A   0-3             
1910  Gorleston               (NSC)    A   P-P
 1910  Lowestoft               (EAL)    A   1-2          Whittaker                         [Lynn represented largely by Lynn St Nicholas]
1921  Bury United                      A   3-0          Belton, Love, Earl
1927  Norwich CEYMS           (NCC)    H   1-3          Marshall
1938  Bury Town               (ECLC)   A   1-2          Snow
1949  Chelmsford City Res              A   2-1         Bishop, Shalcross (own goal)
1966  Corby Town                       A   4-0          Lindsay 2, Chilleystone, Banson
1969  Wellington                       A   1-3          Rudd
1972  Gloucester City                  H   1-0     426  Lindsay
1983  Hyde United                      A   0-2     725
1991  Tamworth                         A   0-4    1012
1994  Tamworth                         A   2-2     604  Jones. Gallagher  
2000  Havant & Waterlooville           H   0-1     720
2005  Bath City                        H   0-2     915
2008  Hemel Hempstead        (EC)      H   1-1     385  Kelleher                                         [AET 5-3 on pens] 
2011  Peterborough Northern Star       H   3-1    741  J Thurlbourne 2, J Defty                                       3
2019  Royston Town                     H   4-2    389  Marriott, Fryatt, Gash, Brathwaite Own goal